Tap to get financing
Commercial Real Estate Loans
Loan Options
Permanent FinancingBridge LoansConstruction LoansLife Company LoansSBA 7(a) LoansSBA 504 Loan ProgramFannie Mae LoansFreddie Mac LoansHUD Multifamily LoansCMBS LoansFix and Flip LoansFind a Lender Yourself
Property Types
All Property TypesRetailOfficeIndustrialApartmentsSelf StorageHotelLandChurchSchoolAuto DealershipAuto Repair ShopCar WashGas StationHealthcareMedical OfficeDental OfficeVeterinaryFitness CenterBowling AlleyConvenience StoreDay Care CenterGolf CourseAnchored Strip CenterRestaurantMarinaWarehouseFuneral Home
Resources
BlogCurrent Mortgage RatesForms and TemplatesGlossaryCRE Insurance by StateVideo LibraryHow to Get a CRE LoanFrequently Asked Questions
Calculators
Commercial Mortgage CalculatorCap Rate CalculatorNOI CalculatorDSCR CalculatorLTV CalculatorLTC CalculatorDebt Yield CalculatorYield Maintenance CalculatorInternal Rate of Return Calculator
For Brokers
About Us
About UsLeadershipTeamContactWe're Hiring
(561) 556-7778
Get financing →
Interest Rates

Today’s rates for a wide range of commercial property and loan types.
Check Today's Rates →

Newly Published
Apr 16 at Commercial Real Estate Loans
The Commercial Mortgage Broker's Guide to LinkedIn
Apr 15 at Commercial Real Estate Loans
Becoming the Go-To Financing Expert in Your CRE Niche
Apr 14 at Commercial Real Estate Loans
Deal Sourcing: Balancing Inbound and Outbound Strategies
Explore the Janover Network
May 8 at HUD Loans
The 2025 Developer's Guide to HUD Lender Matching
Apr 22 at Janover Inc. Investor Relations
Janover Inc. Announces Corporate Name Change to DeFi Development Corporation
Apr 16 at Janover Inc. Investor Relations
Janover Inc. to Host X Spaces Conversation on NAV Premiums
Was This Article Helpful?
Commercial Real Estate Glossary
4 min read

Carve-Out Guarantees in Commercial Real Estate Finance

The carve-out guarantee gives a lender the authority to require payment for a commercial real estate loan beyond the actual value of the property if foreclosure occurs.

In this article:
  1. Carve-Out Guarantees In Commercial Mortgages
  2. ''Bad-Boy'' Carve-Outs
  3. Cave-Out Guaranty Provisions for Borrower Protection 
  4. Carve Out Guarantees and Mezzanine Loans 
  5. Want to learn more? Fill out the form below to speak with an expert commercial mortgage banker.
  6. Related Questions
  7. Get Financing
Start Your Application and Unlock the Power of Choice Experience expert guidance, competitive options, and unparalleled industry expertise.
Click Here to Get Quotes →
$5.6M offered by a Bank$1.2M offered by a Bank$2M offered by an Agency$1.4M offered by a Credit UnionClick Here to Get Quotes!

Carve-Out Guarantees In Commercial Mortgages

A carve-out guarantee, also referred to as a carve-out guaranty, gives a commercial lender the authority go after a borrower’s personal assets if the lender forecloses on the property. Carve-out guarantees are standard on almost all types of non-recourse commercial loans; if they are violated, they essential make the non-recourse loan into a full recourse financial instrument. Depending on the wording of the carve-out guaranty, the lender has the ability to either seek damages or the entire loan amount if there are any violations of the note or commercial mortgage loan agreement.

''Bad-Boy'' Carve-Outs

Also called a “bad boy” carve-out, a carve-out guaranty often applies when the borrower or guarantor of the loan engages in serious violations—like misrepresentations of the property, fraud, theft, or voluntary destruction of real estate—that impact the value of the property or loan. This guarantee therefore gives the lender immediate financial recourse against such acts.

The carve-out guarantee also allows a lender to require payment for a real estate loan if the borrower files for voluntary bankruptcy or conspires with another party to have involuntary bankruptcy filed. The lender can also seek loan repayment or damages if the borrower transfers any part of the commercial real estate that affects its value. Other common “bad boy” acts that could trigger a loan’s recourse provisions include failure to pay required property insurance premiums, failure to pay property taxes, wasting funds, environmental indemnifications, and borrower negligence.

Cave-Out Guaranty Provisions for Borrower Protection 

In many situations today, carve out guarantees are so complex and numerous that a non-recourse loan begins to significantly resemble full recourse financing. That's why borrowers should be careful to make sure that the terms of their non-recourse loan are reasonable and that recourse will not likely be triggered by poor market conditions or small oversights.

In particular, we recommend that a non-recourse loan agreement have the following provisions in regards to carve-outs: 

  • The lender must provide reasonable advance notice a "cure period" for certain carve-outs, such as failure to pay taxes. 

  • If recourse is triggered, the lender must not attempt to seek damages beyond the loan amount they were originally owed (exceptions may include certain legal and administrative costs)

  • The insolvency of the borrowing entity will not trigger the loan’s recourse provisions.

  • Any cash distributions to property owners made before loan default will not be recaptured by the lender.

Carve Out Guarantees and Mezzanine Loans 

Carve-outs can be especially tricky if a borrower has decided to take out mezzanine debt on top of a senior loan. In most cases, mezzanine loan borrowers are required to pledge a controlling equity interest in the borrowing entity as collateral for their loan. If a borrower defaults their mezzanine loan, the mezzanine lender could then take control over the property; and, in theory, could commit various acts that would violate a loan's carve-out provisions, such as declaring bankruptcy or failing to pay property taxes.

In this situation, the original loan borrower could be held liable, even if they no longer have any control over the operation and finances of the property itself. For this reason, it's essential that borrowers who are considering taking on mezzanine debt make sure they are legally protected. However, this protection does not only benefit borrowers, it protects the senior lender as well. For example, if a borrowing entity controlled by a mezzanine lender declared bankruptcy, it could prevent the lender from actually foreclosing upon the property. To prevent these types of unfortunate legal scenarios, senior lenders sometimes require a mezzanine lender to indemnify the borrower against all outs in the case that the mezzanine lender takes control of the borrowing entity.

Want to learn more? Fill out the form below to speak with an expert commercial mortgage banker.

Related Questions

What is a carve-out guarantee in commercial real estate finance?

A carve-out guarantee, also referred to as a carve-out guaranty, gives a commercial lender the authority go after a borrower’s personal assets if the lender forecloses on the property. Carve-out guarantees are standard on almost all types of non-recourse commercial loans; if they are violated, they essential make the non-recourse loan into a full recourse financial instrument. Depending on the wording of the carve-out guaranty, the lender has the ability to either seek damages or the entire loan amount if there are any violations of the note or commercial mortgage loan agreement.

Also called a “bad boy” carve-out, a carve-out guaranty often applies when the borrower or guarantor of the loan engages in serious violations—like misrepresentations of the property, fraud, theft, or voluntary destruction of real estate—that impact the value of the property or loan. This guarantee therefore gives the lender immediate financial recourse against such acts.

The carve-out guarantee also allows a lender to require payment for a real estate loan if the borrower files for voluntary bankruptcy or conspires with another party to have involuntary bankruptcy filed. The lender can also seek loan repayment or damages if the borrower transfers any part of the commercial real estate that affects its value. Other common “bad boy” acts that could trigger a loan’s recourse provisions include failure to pay required property insurance premiums, failure to pay property taxes, wasting funds, environmental indemnifications, and borrower negligence.

What are the benefits of a carve-out guarantee?

The benefits of a carve-out guarantee are that it gives a commercial lender the authority to go after a borrower’s personal assets if the lender forecloses on the property. This is standard on almost all types of non-recourse commercial loans, and if the carve-out guaranty is violated, it essentially makes the non-recourse loan into a full recourse financial instrument. Depending on the wording of the carve-out guaranty, the lender has the ability to either seek damages or the entire loan amount if there are any violations of the note or commercial mortgage loan agreement.

In addition, borrowers should be careful to make sure that the terms of their non-recourse loan are reasonable and that recourse will not likely be triggered by poor market conditions or small oversights. We recommend that a non-recourse loan agreement have the following provisions in regards to carve-outs:

  • The lender must provide reasonable advance notice a "cure period" for certain carve-outs, such as failure to pay taxes.
  • If recourse is triggered, the lender must not attempt to seek damages beyond the loan amount they were originally owed (exceptions may include certain legal and administrative costs).
  • The insolvency of the borrowing entity will not trigger the loan’s recourse provisions.
  • Any cash distributions to property owners made before loan default will not be recaptured by the lender.

What are the risks associated with a carve-out guarantee?

The main risk associated with a carve-out guarantee is that it can turn a non-recourse loan into a full recourse loan if the terms of the loan agreement are violated. This means that the lender can seek damages or the entire loan amount if there are any violations of the note or commercial mortgage loan agreement. It is important for borrowers to make sure that the terms of their non-recourse loan are reasonable and that recourse will not likely be triggered by poor market conditions or small oversights.

We recommend that a non-recourse loan agreement have the following provisions in regards to carve-outs:

  • The lender must provide reasonable advance notice a "cure period" for certain carve-outs, such as failure to pay taxes.
  • If recourse is triggered, the lender must not attempt to seek damages beyond the loan amount they were originally owed (exceptions may include certain legal and administrative costs).
  • The insolvency of the borrowing entity will not trigger the loan’s recourse provisions.
  • Any cash distributions to property owners made before loan default will not be recaptured by the lender.

How does a carve-out guarantee work in commercial real estate finance?

A carve-out guarantee, also referred to as a carve-out guaranty, gives a commercial lender the authority to go after a borrower’s personal assets if the lender forecloses on the property. Carve-out guarantees are standard on almost all types of non-recourse commercial loans; if they are violated, they essentially make the non-recourse loan into a full recourse financial instrument. Depending on the wording of the carve-out guaranty, the lender has the ability to either seek damages or the entire loan amount if there are any violations of the note or commercial mortgage loan agreement.

Also called a “bad boy” carve-out, a carve-out guaranty often applies when the borrower or guarantor of the loan engages in serious violations—like misrepresentations of the property, fraud, theft, or voluntary destruction of real estate—that impact the value of the property or loan. This guarantee therefore gives the lender immediate financial recourse against such acts.

The carve-out guarantee also allows a lender to require payment for a real estate loan if the borrower files for voluntary bankruptcy or conspires with another party to have involuntary bankruptcy filed. The lender can also seek loan repayment or damages if the borrower transfers any part of the commercial real estate that affects its value. Other common “bad boy” acts that could trigger a loan’s recourse provisions include failure to pay required property insurance premiums, failure to pay property taxes, wasting funds, environmental indemnifications, and borrower negligence.

What are the different types of carve-out guarantees available in commercial real estate finance?

Carve-out guarantees in commercial real estate finance are typically standard on almost all types of non-recourse commercial loans. Depending on the wording of the carve-out guaranty, the lender has the ability to either seek damages or the entire loan amount if there are any violations of the note or commercial mortgage loan agreement.

A carve-out guarantee also applies when the borrower or guarantor of the loan engages in serious violations—like misrepresentations of the property, fraud, theft, or voluntary destruction of real estate—that impact the value of the property or loan. This guarantee therefore gives the lender immediate financial recourse against such acts.

The carve-out guarantee also allows a lender to require payment for a real estate loan if the borrower files for voluntary bankruptcy or conspires with another party to have involuntary bankruptcy filed. The lender can also seek loan repayment or damages if the borrower transfers any part of the commercial real estate that affects its value. Other common “bad boy” acts that could trigger a loan’s recourse provisions include failure to pay required property insurance premiums, failure to pay property taxes, wasting funds, environmental indemnifications, and borrower negligence.

In this article:
  1. Carve-Out Guarantees In Commercial Mortgages
  2. ''Bad-Boy'' Carve-Outs
  3. Cave-Out Guaranty Provisions for Borrower Protection 
  4. Carve Out Guarantees and Mezzanine Loans 
  5. Want to learn more? Fill out the form below to speak with an expert commercial mortgage banker.
  6. Related Questions
  7. Get Financing
Categories
  • Commercial Mortgages
  • Commercial Property Loans
Tags
  • Carve-Out Guarantee
  • "Bad-Boy" Carve-Out
  • Recourse Debt
  • Commercial Real Estate Loans

Getting commercial property financing should be easy.⁠ Now it is.

Click below for a free, no obligation quote and to learn more about your loan options.

Get financing →

Janover: Your Partner in Growth

At Janover, we offer a wide range of services tailored to your unique needs. From commercial property loans and LP management to business loans and services for lenders, we're here to help you succeed.

Learn more about Janover →
Commercial Property Loans

Get the best CRE financing on the market.

Explore Financing Options →
LP Management

Syndicate deals on autopilot with Janover Connect.

Discover LP Management →
Business Loans

Match with the right kind of loan, in record time.

Find Business Loans →
For Lenders

Supercharge your loan pipeline. Unlock more deals.

Boost Your Loan Pipeline →
Commercial Real Estate Loans

Commercial Real Estate Loans is a Janover company. Please visit some of our family of sites at: Multifamily Loans, Commercial Real Estate Loans, SBA7a Loans, HUD Loans, Janover Insurance, Janover Pro, Janover Connect, and Janover Engage.

Janover Tech Inc.

6401 Congress Ave
Ste 250
Boca Raton FL 33487
(561) 556-7778 
hello@commercialrealestate.loans

Commercial Real Estate Loans

Eligible Property Types
Mortgage Rates
Commercial Loan Calculator
Glossary
CRE Loan Guides per State
For Commercial Mortgage Brokers

Site Information

Privacy Policy
Terms of Use


For Commercial Mortgage Brokers

This website is owned by a company that offers business advice, information and other services related to multifamily, commercial real estate, and business financing. We have no affiliation with any government agency and are not a lender. We are a technology company that uses software and experience to bring lenders and borrowers together. By using this website, you agree to our use of cookies, our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy. We use cookies to provide you with a great experience and to help our website run effectively.

Freddie Mac® and Optigo® are registered trademarks of Freddie Mac. Fannie Mae® is a registered trademark of Fannie Mae. We are not affiliated with the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), Federal Housing Administration (FHA), Freddie Mac or Fannie Mae.

This website utilizes artificial intelligence technologies to auto-generate responses, which have limitations in accuracy and appropriateness. Users should not rely upon AI-generated content for definitive advice and instead should confirm facts or consult professionals regarding any personal, legal, financial or other matters. The website owner is not responsible for damages allegedly arising from use of this website's AI.

Copyright © 2025 Janover Tech Inc. All rights reserved.

+

Fill out the form below and get the pricing and terms banks can't compete with.